Client has newer version of certificate than the Server

Question

Let's say i have to certificate with both common name being foo.bar.com

i put one in my server and i put one in the client.

the server one has older version and the client has newer version.

the different between the older and newer version is:

1. The private key is different that is used to generate the csr is different
2. The Expiry date is different

If the client hit a request to the server, can the request be passed normally? Or will it get blocked saying SSL Missmatch or something?

Thanks.