'SWIG: avoid C++-to-Python aliasing
I am building a library in C++ which is interfaced to Python 3 using SWIG 4.0.1. After some time developing I noticed a problem with (what I think is called) aliasing. I prepared a minimal example which this also happens.
Consider the class dummy with a single (private) attribute attr which is initialized at 0. Now, I have this really small python script:
import dummy_wrap
d1 = dummy_wrap.dummy()
d2 = d1
d1.set_attr(12)
print(d2.get_attr()) # this prints '12', not '0'
I hope that what I call aliasing is what is really happening here: object d2 is never modified, yet it takes the value given to d1, as if the assignment d2=d1 was actually pointer assignment. What I would like to happen (and also what I expect to happen) is that the assignment operator a=b makes a hard copy of b passes it onto a. In other words, modifications to a should not affect b and viceversa, as long as this meets the implementation details (as is the case in my library and in the minimal example).
As a final note, this is the messages I get when compiling:
g++ -fPIC -c dummy.cpp
g++ -fPIC -shared -o libdummy_lib.so dummy.o
swig -Wall -c++ -python -py3 -o dummy_wrap.cxx dummy_wrap.i
dummy.hpp:10: Warning 362: operator= ignored
dummy.hpp:11: Warning 362: operator= ignored
dummy.hpp:7: Warning 509: Overloaded method dummy::dummy(dummy &&) effectively ignored,
dummy.hpp:6: Warning 509: as it is shadowed by dummy::dummy(dummy const &).
g++ -fPIC -c dummy_wrap.cxx -I /usr/include/python3.8
g++ -fPIC -shared -o _dummy_wrap.so dummy_wrap.o -L . -ldummy_lib -lpython3.8
Questions:
- I would like to understand what is happening here and why: do the
dummy(dummy&&)anddummy& operator=(dummy&&)affect how SWIG wrapsdummy(const dummy&)anddummy& operator=(const dummy&)? - Is it reasonable to expect what I would like to have as default behavior, namely, is this (aliasing) the expected behavior of the class after interfacing to python using SWIG?
- How can I fix this: what changes should I make so that the operator
=makes a hard copy?
Thanks a lot in advance.
In order to replicate this, the class header dummy.hpp is:
#pragma once
class dummy {
public:
dummy() = default;
dummy(const dummy&) = default;
dummy(dummy&&) = default;
~dummy() = default;
dummy& operator=(const dummy&) = default;
dummy& operator=(dummy&&) = default;
void set_attr(int v);
int get_attr() const;
private:
int attr = 0;
};
and the class implementation dummy.cpp is simply
#include "dummy.hpp"
void dummy::set_attr(int v) { attr = v; }
int dummy::get_attr() const { return attr; }
the interface file dummy_wrap.i is:
%module dummy_wrap
%{
#include "dummy.hpp"
%}
%include "dummy.hpp"
and the Makefile I use to compile and link everything is
all: libdummy_lib.so _dummy_wrap.so
_dummy_wrap.so: dummy_wrap.o
g++ -fPIC -shared -o _dummy_wrap.so dummy_wrap.o -L . -ldummy_lib -lpython3.8
dummy_wrap.o: dummy_wrap.cxx
g++ -std=c++17 -fPIC -c dummy_wrap.cxx -I /usr/include/python3.8
dummy_wrap.cxx: dummy_wrap.i
swig -Wall -c++ -python -py3 -o dummy_wrap.cxx dummy_wrap.i
libdummy_lib.so: dummy.o
g++ -fPIC -shared -o libdummy_lib.so dummy.o
dummy.o: dummy.cpp dummy.hpp
g++ -std=c++17 -fPIC -c dummy.cpp
clean:
rm -f libdummy_lib.so dummy.o
rm -f _dummy_wrap.so dummy_wrap.o dummy_wrap.cxx dummy_wrap.py
In linux, remember to update the LD_LIBRARY_PATH using:
export LD_LIBRARY_PATH=$LD_LIBRARY_PATH:.
Sources
This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Overflow and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Source: Stack Overflow
| Solution | Source |
|---|
